Struggling with a severely broken‑down tooth and no ferrule? Not sure whether to extract, perform crown lengthening, or look for another solution? This comprehensive, chairside‑friendly guide will help you evaluate restorability, understand when and how to perform esthetic vs functional crown lengthening, protect the supracrestal tissue attachment (biologic width), preserve keratinized gingiva, and gain the tooth structure you need for a predictable final restoration.

The Clinical Dilemma: No Ferrule—Now What?

You’ve got a badly destructed tooth. There’s little to no supragingival tooth structure, and the margin you’ll need for a crown drops subgingivally. You’re asking:

• Is the tooth restorable?

• Should I extract and implant?

• Can I gain vertical tooth structure surgically (crown lengthening) and save it?

• Will the resulting crown‑to‑root ratio be acceptable?

This article gives you an evidence‑informed framework to answer those questions, beginning with biologic limits and moving through surgical technique and aftercare.

---

What Is Crown Lengthening?

Crown lengthening is a periodontal surgical procedure performed to increase the amount of clinically exposed tooth structure. This can be accomplished by removing gingival tissue, alveolar bone, or both, often combined with apical repositioning of the flap. The goal depends on the indication:

• Improve restorative access/retention (functional crown lengthening).

• Correct excessive gingival display or gingival overgrowth (esthetic crown lengthening).

---

Esthetic vs Functional (Restorative) Crown Lengthening

Indication Type	Typical Patient Presentation	Main Tissue Change	Primary Goal
Esthetic	Gummy smile, altered passive eruption, uneven gingival scallop, gingival overgrowth (drug‑induced, inflammatory)	Often soft tissue ± minimal bone	Harmonize smile line; ideal gingival symmetry & zeniths
Functional / Restorative	Subgingival caries, cervical/root fracture, short clinical crown for retention/resistance, subgingival restorative margin	Often requires osseous recontouring + apically positioned flap	Expose sound tooth structure; re‑establish supracrestal tissue attachment; create ferrule

Remember: Some cases are blended—esthetic need plus deep margins. Plan with both outcomes in mind.

---

Core Biological Principles

Successful crown lengthening rests on protecting two key periodontal parameters:

Supracrestal Tissue Attachment (Biologic Width)

Formerly called biologic width, the supracrestal tissue attachment (STA) is the combined junctional epithelium + supracrestal connective tissue attachment coronal to the alveolar crest. Clinically, we preserve this attachment by ensuring an adequate vertical distance between the restorative margin and the crestal bone.

Clinical Rule of Thumb: Maintain ~3.0 mm from the planned restorative margin to the crest of bone (≈2 mm attachment + ≈1 mm sulcus). Individual variation exists; use bone sounding to customize.

read this article Deep Caries Management: Step-by-Step Guide

Keratinized / Attached Gingiva

A stable zone of keratinized gingiva (KG) helps with plaque control, tissue resistance, margin stability, and long‑term periodontal health—especially when margins are at or slightly subgingival.

Minimum target: Aim to preserve ≥2 mm keratinized tissue (with at least ~1 mm attached) whenever possible. In thin biotypes or high esthetic zones, more is better. If the existing KG is minimal and a gingivectomy would eliminate it, choose an apically positioned flap (or consider soft‑tissue grafting) instead of simple excision.

---

Ferrule: Definition, Biomechanics & Minimum Dimensions

A ferrule is a circumferential collar of sound tooth structure above the finish line that is grasped by the final restoration. It acts like a reinforcing metal band on a barrel—helping resist functional leverage, wedging forces from posts, and catastrophic root fracture.

Why It Matters

• Increases retention and resistance form.

• Reduces vertical root fracture and post debonding risk.

• Improves marginal seal → lowers microleakage and recurrent caries.

Minimum Dimensions Commonly Recommended

• Height: At least 1.5–2.0 mm (more improves prognosis). Some evidence suggests even 1 mm adds benefit, but aim higher when feasible.

• Thickness (dentin wall): Strive for ≥1 mm sound dentin circumferentially; thinner walls compromise strength.

• Completeness: A 360° ferrule is ideal. Partial ferrules still help—prioritize the walls that bear functional load (palatal of maxillary anteriors; buccal/lingual of posteriors).

Planning Tip: When endodontically treated teeth require a post and crown, you may need 4–5 mm of total clearance from the planned restoration margin to the bone to accommodate both ferrule and STA. Work backward from your planned finish line.

---

Stepwise Diagnostic Work‑Up

Before you pick up a scalpel, confirm the tooth is worth saving.

1. Medical & Periodontal Baseline

• Systemic health, bleeding risk, meds (e.g., anticoagulants, bisphosphonates).

• Plaque control & periodontal status—stabilize inflammation first.

2. Phase I Therapy

Perform scaling/root planing and remove calculus. Working in a clean field improves tissue response and accuracy of measurements.

3. Caries & Defect Removal Before Final Surgical Planning

Excavate caries and remove undermined tooth structure. Your ferrule measurement is meaningless until all infected tissue is gone.

4. Endodontic Status

• Confirm adequate root canal therapy and apical seal.

• If a post will be needed, consider post length vs remaining root length.

5. Crown‑to‑Root Ratio

Obtain periapical radiographs (CBCT if indicated). After proposed surgery, will enough root remain in bone to support function? A minimum 1:1 clinical crown‑to‑root ratio is often cited as workable; better ratios improve prognosis.

6. Measure Keratinized Tissue Width

From free gingival margin to mucogingival junction. Note attached portion (KG – sulcus depth).

7. Bone Sounding (See next section)

Under local anesthesia, probe to bone to map the vertical dimension of STA at each surface.

8. Esthetic Smile Analysis (Anterior Cases)

• High vs low smile line.

• Gingival symmetry, zenith positions, incisal edge display.

---

Bone Sounding: How to Decide Soft‑Tissue Only vs Osseous Surgery

Technique: After local anesthesia, insert a calibrated probe (UNC‑15) through the sulcus to bone. Record the distance from the free gingival margin to the alveolar crest.

Interpretation Guide

• ≈2 mm or less: There is no room for the 3 mm biologic complex. Soft‑tissue removal alone would violate STA. Plan osseous reduction (osteotomy) with an apically positioned flap.

• ≈4 mm or more: You likely have enough STA + sulcus to perform a soft‑tissue gingivectomy (if adequate keratinized tissue remains after excision) without touching bone.

• Borderline / Inadequate Keratinized Tissue (<2 mm): Avoid simple gingivectomy. Use an apically positioned flap, possibly with simultaneous osseous recontouring, to preserve or reposition KG.

---

Decision Matrix: Gingivectomy? Apically Positioned Flap? Osteotomy? Extraction?

Quick Chairside Flow:

1. Is the tooth restorable after caries removal?

   • No → Consider extraction / implant / bridge.

   • Yes → continue.

2. Remaining root length sufficient for acceptable crown‑to‑root ratio post‑surgery?

   • No → Consider alternative (extraction, orthodontic extrusion).

   • Yes → continue.

3. Bone sounding ≥4 mm AND ≥2 mm KG remains after proposed soft‑tissue removal?

   • Yes → Gingivectomy / Gingivoplasty may suffice.

   • No → continue.

4. Bone sounding <3 mm (insufficient STA) → Osseous recontouring (osteotomy/osteoplasty) + apically positioned flap.

5. KG <2 mm pre‑op → Use apically positioned flap (don’t excise what little you have); consider grafting.

6. Need ≥1.5–2 mm ferrule & subgingival defect extends deep → May require 4–5 mm bone reduction relative to planned margin; reassess crown‑to‑root ratio before committing.

7. Patient esthetic demands & high smile line? Blend esthetic crown lengthening principles (gingival symmetry, zenith control) with functional exposure.

---

Surgical Protocol: Functional Crown Lengthening (Clinical Steps)

Below is a practical sequence you can adapt. Instrument brands are examples—use what you prefer.

Pre‑Surgical Set‑Up

• Confirm restorative plan, margin location, ferrule target.

• Mark proposed finish line on tooth (temporary or pencil transfer).

• Ensure profound local anesthesia.

• Pack gauze soaked in saline for visibility.

Marking the Gingival Zeniths & Bleeding Points

Use a periodontal probe or pocket marker to place bleeding points at intended new gingival margin heights. Remember typical zenith locations:

• Maxillary centrals: Slightly distal to midline.

• Maxillary laterals: Approximately midline.

• Maxillary canines: Slightly distal again.
  Connect points with a light scoring line (back of a scalpel blade) to guide uniform tissue removal.

Soft‑Tissue Reduction (Gingivectomy / Gingivoplasty)

Excise the collar of gingiva to your guide line using scalpel, electrosurgery, or laser. Refine contours to reproduce natural scallop.

Flap Reflection & Osseous Recontouring (Osteotomy / Osteoplasty)

If bone reduction is required:

1. Create sulcular or submarginal incisions depending on KG width.

2. Elevate a full‑thickness mucoperiosteal flap (buccal ± lingual/palatal) to expose crestal bone.

3. Using end‑cutting bur, round carbide, piezo, or laser, perform osteotomy to position bone crest the required distance apical to the planned restoration margin (~3 mm for STA; more if ferrule needed).

4. Blend irregularities with osteoplasty for physiologic architecture.

5. Verify measurements at all surfaces; interproximal areas are easy to miss.

Irrigation, Hemostasis & Suturing

• Copious saline irrigation; remove debris.

• Confirm smooth osseous profile with probe.

• Reposition flap apically to desired level.

• Modified vertical mattress suturing sequence (example for a single site): apical buccal → apical lingual → crestal lingual → crestal buccal; tie to secure apical position and close papillae. Sling sutures are useful in multi‑tooth cases.

---

Closed / Flapless Crown Lengthening: When Is It Appropriate?

In carefully selected cases—adequate sulcus depth, thick tissue, limited bone removal, favorable anatomy—a flapless (closed) crown lengthening approach may be used. Techniques include laser‑assisted soft‑tissue removal combined with transgingival (through‑tissue) osseous contouring using lasers, piezo tips, or specially designed burs under magnification. Advantages may include reduced chair time, less bleeding, and faster recovery; limitations are reduced visualization and tactile control. Reserve for minimally invasive indications and experienced operators.

---

Post‑Operative Instructions

Provide written instructions; review verbally before discharge.

Pain Control

• Paracetamol (acetaminophen) first line.

• Add/alternate ibuprofen for stronger analgesia if no contraindications.

Antibiotics

• Prescribe only when clinically indicated (extensive osseous surgery, systemic risk, contamination). Emphasize completing the full course.

Cold Therapy

• Apply ice pack externally: 15 minutes on / 15 minutes off during the first 24 hours to reduce swelling.

Bleeding Control

• Mild oozing is normal for 24 hours. If persistent, apply firm pressure with folded sterile gauze for 20 minutes.

Oral Hygiene & Rinsing

• No vigorous rinsing for 24 hours.

• After 24h: Gentle rinse twice daily with chlorhexidine (e.g., 0.12%) for 1–2 weeks or warm salt water 3–4×/day if CHX unavailable/taste sensitive.

• Brush other areas normally; clean surgical site carefully per instructions.

Diet

• Soft, cool foods first 24h; avoid hot/spicy foods that may trigger bleeding.

Activity

• Limit strenuous activity for 24–48h.

Follow‑Up

• Review at 7–10 days for suture removal and soft‑tissue assessment.

---

Healing Timeline & When to Restore

Healing time depends on the extent of surgery, tissue biotype, and esthetic demands.

Typical Milestones

• First 24–48h: Swelling, mild bleeding/oozing expected.

• 1 Week: Discomfort largely resolved; sutures often removed.

• 2–3 Weeks: Soft tissues forming early contour; patient resumes normal hygiene.

• 6–8 Weeks: Functional stability in many posterior cases; provisional margins can be adjusted.

• 8+ Weeks (≈2 Months): Safer window to begin definitive restorative steps after moderate osseous recontouring.

• 3–6 Months: Greater positional stability of the gingival margin—recommended for highly esthetic anterior cases or extensive multi‑tooth crown lengthening before final impressions.

Clinical Pearl: Tissue rebound (coronal creep) can occur, especially interproximally. Delay definitive margin placement in the esthetic zone until soft tissue levels have stabilized.

---

Quick FAQ for the Busy Clinician

Q: Minimum ferrule needed? Aim for 1.5–2 mm height wherever possible; even partial ferrule helps.

Q: How much bone to remove? Enough to create ~3 mm from planned margin to bone plus the ferrule you need. In post‑core cases you may need 4–5 mm total.

Q: Can I do gingivectomy only? Yes—if bone sounding shows you already have ≥3 mm STA coronal to bone and you’ll retain ≥2 mm keratinized gingiva after excision.

Q: What if keratinized gingiva is <2 mm? Do not simply excise. Use an apically positioned flap (possibly with grafting) to preserve or increase KG.

Q: Closed crown lengthening—safe? In limited, well‑selected cases with minimal osseous changes. Requires magnification and precise tools (e.g., lasers, piezo tips).

Q: When can I take final impressions? Posterior functional cases: ~6–8+ weeks if tissue stable. High‑smile esthetic zones or major osseous reshaping: 2–3 months (or longer if tissue migration observed).

---

Clinical Checklist (Print‑Friendly)

Pre‑Op

• Medical history reviewed

• Plaque/calculus control (Phase I complete)

• Caries/debris removed; true margin identified

• Endodontic status verified

• Crown‑root ratio acceptable

• Keratinized gingiva width measured

• Bone sounding charted (B, L/P, M, D)

• Ferrule target marked

• Patient consent & esthetic expectations reviewed

Intra‑Op

• Gingival zeniths marked (bleeding points)

• Soft‑tissue excision performed

• Flap reflected as indicated

• Osseous reduction measured to target

• Irrigation / smooth contours

• Apically reposition & suture (modified vertical mattress / sling)

Post‑Op

• Written instructions given (pain meds, rinses, ice, activity)

• Follow‑up booked 7–10 days

• Timeline for provisional / final restoration explained